I have a confession to make. In high school, I was an amazing cheater. Although my abilities could certainly be questioned as immoral, I justified them by telling myself that I was being creative by developing new, and exciting methods of getting away with it, and then saying to myself that this was "true studying," and that I was actually learning the material better this way! This brings me to a little story, that poses a whole new question that isn't related to cheating at all...stay with me... (this reminds me, if anyone needs help recognizing when a student is cheating, I know all the tricks!).
I am terrible at languages, I hit the barrier as soon as someone has so much as a slight accent when speaking English. With this in mind, imagine how I struggled with learning French, especially in high school where, of course, I believed that I would "never have to use this."
It was grade 11 French class with a teacher I just couldn't tolerate, she drove me to sign out to the bathroom a good 5 times a class (and my addiction to coffee is only recent). Obviously, my visits to the urinal were not in all honesty, as I found myself meandering the halls in search of friends and better things to do than play "Simon says" in a language that I understood as gibberish...Didn't matter, I was the first one out anyway for touching my knee instead of my nose. During my strolls, I usually ended up in a computers class where I had a bunch of friends (don't worry, the cheating thing comes back soon) who were being taught by what we thought was a "cool" young, new teacher.
Well, one day, I had an final oral examination for French that included presenting a topic en francais (not bad heh?) to the entire class. I really wanted to do well, and show my teacher that I had worked very hard in order to meet the course requirements and basically get the hell out of there with a passing grade.
A couple days earlier my friends and I bought these pretty sweet two-way radios that we figured would be good to throw in the car and stay in touch (how cool were we?). These radios however soon proved to assist me in another way, especially when considering you could attach an ear jack to them and wire it up my sleeves into my long hair without anyone having the slightest clue about it. I had a "eureka moment," and realized that I could have someone outside feed me my French presentation word for word.
Now, my best friends who would help me were in the computers class with that "cool" teacher I referred to earlier, who we thought would totally let them out of class to pay me a visit as I did to them so often. Well, this teacher got word of my plan through a friend and approached me about it. I was screwed, not only was he going to inform my teacher, but now I had done absolutely no memorizing of my lines. This, was not the case. That teacher thought my idea was so hilarious and impressive that he not only allowed it, but he actually read out a couple lines of my presentation to help me get an A!
So, if you have been able to slog yourself through my story, here is the question I have. If you are a teacher and you feel that a colleague of yours has a very unprofessional relationship with a student(s), what do you do about it? If you were a teacher and you saw this occurring in your school, how would you address the situation, because that situation was obviously unethical (which I knew then, but KNOW now)? Should you stay out of it and believe that it will all get back to him/her, or would you get involved to not only protect that colleague in the future, but to keep the school in environment free of such behavior? Would you get the administration involved, or would that create a tension that would end up jeopardizing your career and/or relationship with other staff members? My example is a pretty odd one, but I think there will be times when you question your colleagues behavior(s) and be confused as to handle or possibly ignore the situation...
Wednesday, July 9, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
5 comments:
Hahahhaaa!! I really like your honesty in this situation Geordy! I think everyone has cheated on one or more occasion during their accademic careers (whether admitted or not) and to some extent I almost think those small cases aren't a problem.
Now before someone gets their back up over that comment, I'm just saying that to me if someone "borrows" a starting thought for an essay, or needs that jump start to the correct answer on a test (by peeping over a shoulder to see a key word) than that's a LOT less of an offense than blatantly plagiarising a whole work. I think it will also be how much we are each able to deal with as well. I mean i'm not going to turn a blind eye, and especially not going to actually ASSIST cheating (sorry Geordy), but if it's small enough for me not to 'see' it, then I think I won't worry too much.
I'm also going to try to make a point of utilizing a lot of group and collaborative work for evaluation so that it isn't always only the individual work that is what counts towards the grades.
All in all I think this is a pretty funny post and, like much of what we discuss on this blog or in class, a situation like this will be situationally dealt with and as we grow and become more experienced, we will find what we're comfortable with.
Great story telling! To answer about that teacher helping you cheat...'cool' but yeah, he could have run himself into a bit of trouble - again, choosing what you stand for at chosen times will be important (see BCTF code of ethics that you all agree to when you become a union member: http://bctf.ca/ProfessionalResponsibility.aspx?id=4292 [cut and paste this link].
That said, what kind of assignments are being given out by teachers that enable cheating? I think Danika is wise in planning assessment that tries to avoid the types of evaluation that stress students out and don't futher their learning... we'll chat more on Friday about these possibilities!
Your story was awesome Geordy. It is amazing how truly clever high school students can be!! I do have a negative opinion about the teacher who helped you cheat. Basically, it should never have happened. If I found out about a colleague of mine that was assisting a student cheat, I would immediately report them. It is true that teachers need to support one another, but that support should cease when they are jeopardizing a students right to learn.
It is important to be careful we are not enabling cheating through the assignments we give, but we should never turn a blind eye or assist cheating in any way. The problem with cheating is that it gets easier and more desirable the more students do it. There are severe penalties for even minor cheating in university and most jobs. It is part of a teacher's responsibility to not allow student cheating habits to form.
I will have zero-tolerance for cheating in my classes, as I think it shows a complete lack of respect for the teacher, education and the student him/herself. It also poses the problem of unfair assessment. How can we assess and give feedback to students if the work they show us or the tests they write are not their own?
My background on this topic comes from the BC Assoc. of Professional Engineers, so it's a little more strict when it comes to narc-ing on colleagues. If an engineer cuts corners, or doesn't follow the rules - someone dies. Not every situation is that serious, but I was trained to treat them all with that level of seriousness. My duty was to immediately report any concerns to the association, if there was any evidence of a colleague being "unprofessional" in their duties.
However, my immediate reaction in the case described would be to confront the teacher, not the administration, as his/her actions were not directly dangerous to anyone. The "cool" teacher simply may not have realized the consequences of what he/she was doing. Had they given a second thought to it, they might not have "helped out" with the presentation. As a result of being put on notice by a fellow teacher, I find it hard to believe that they would try something like that again.
In a lot of things (other than engineering, obviously), I believe that everyone gets 1 "free pass" - you can't drop the hammer on their first mistake of this kind, but you have to give a warning so that they know it was a mistake. Second time around, they didn't learn from it - then there has to be consequences.
To Leanna's comment "what kind of assignments are being given out by teachers that enable cheating?" -
I think Geordy proved that if one is determined enough, it's possible to cheat on just about anything. I think a better way to phrase it would be "what kind of assignments are being given out by teachers that encourage students to cheat?".
Excellent story, btw.
Amazing story, showing the resourcefulness and cleverness of students, and that’s not even factoring in today’s technology.
It would definitely be a tricky situation if you found out that a teacher was assisting students cheating, and even more so, if you were only new to staff, and the teacher in question was more senior etc. I liked Donal’s angle about giving everyone a second chance. While I understand Ellie’s angle – and I am not trying to be confrontational here - I think that it would be very difficult to report on another teacher, without talking and confronting the teacher in question first. I am all against cheating, and think that it should definitely be punished, and especially that it shows a lack of respect, but when there’s social relations with other members of staff etc, the situation can get complicated. When I start teaching, there will definitely be a tendency not to “rock the boat”. I want to get hired!!!
Anyway, the point I originally wanted to make before going off on a tangent, is that Geordy’s story shows that we should never underestimate students and the ends that they might go to. If Geordy’s teacher in question had suspected the walkie-talkie situation, I’m sure that he/she would have felt that they were suffering severe paranoia.
Post a Comment